Posts tagged ‘geopolitics’
Turn Off TV – Emperor Media Has No Clothes!
Famous Danish author Hans Christian Andersen told a renowned fairy tale of an emperor who was conned into believing he is wearing an invisible suit. The crowd was too embarrassed to acknowledge his nakedness, so they pretend to not notice – until a young boy shouted, “The emperor has no clothes!”
Much like the fairy tale, when it comes to pointing out the many shortcomings of the financial media, I have no problem yelling, “The Emperor Media has no clothes!”
Media Spreads Fear and Misinformation
Mark Twain famously stated, “If you don’t read the newspaper, you’re uninformed. If you read the newspaper, you’re misinformed.” That sentiment rings especially true amid today’s swirl of alarming headlines. Here’s a sampling of recent media-induced worries:
- Global trade war caused by tariffs
- Declining value of the U.S. dollar
- Rising interest rates due to foreign debt sales
- Doubts over the U.S. dollar’s global reserve currency status
- Recession anxiety
- Stagflation fears
- Concerns about Executive Branch overreach
- Threats to remove the Federal Reserve Chairman
Is the sky falling? Is now the time to sell stocks, as the media often implies? Or are these risks being overstated and distorted by media outlets that chase monetary gains?
Issues are More Gray Than Black or White
Journalists – most of whom have little investing experience – like to authoritatively paint economic issues in black-or-white terms. But most reasonable people understand that these matters are complex, and the truth lies somewhere in the gray. To claim the media offers a balanced view of both the positives and negatives of complicated financial topics would be disingenuous.
I have been investing for over 30 years, and while I’ve never faced a global rebalancing of trade impacting trillions in economic activity, I’ve lived through far more uncertain times. Not only have my investments survived those volatile periods, but they have also thrived – repeatedly hitting new record highs.
F.U.D. Sells!
Does the media want you to believe the accurate, long-term stock market prosperity story? Hardly. As the saying goes, “If it bleeds, it leads.” Fear, uncertainty, and doubt (F.U.D.) sell more ads, subscriptions, newspapers, and magazines. The more blood, sweat, and anxiety in the headlines, the more money the media makes from distressed readers.
Behavioral finance pioneers, Nobel Prize winner Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, showed that losses feel twice as painful as the pleasure of gains (see the Pleasure/Pain diagram below). Their Prospect Theory remains just as relevant today as when it was introduced in the late 1970s.
The greatest investor of all-time, Warren Buffett, once said, “Be fearful when others are greedy, and greedy when others are fearful.” Unfortunately, the media pushes the opposite mantra: “sell fear and buy greed.” When markets fall, they sell Armageddon. When markets soar, they sell nirvana. During periods of over-optimism, they also exploit FOMO (Fear of Missing Out) by feasting on investors’ emotional cycle of excitement.
Reassuring long-term investors that everything will be okay—or that dips are buying opportunities—doesn’t generate as much media profits and ad sales. Fear does.
History Doesn’t Repeat Itself, But It Often Rhymes
Too many investors suffer from short-term thinking and goldfish-like memory. But as Mark Twain wisely stated, “History doesn’t repeat itself, but It often rhymes.” And history has shown that listening to the media during times of extreme market volatility often leads to poor decisions.
Let’s take a look at some key examples where media-driven fear was more misleading than helpful over the decades:
The Nifty Fifty Collapse (1973-1974)
In the early 1970s, long before the “Magnificent 7” stocks came to the fore, we had the “Nifty Fifty” stocks. These large-cap blue chip stocks traded at lofty P/E (Price-Earnings) ratios and were seen as invincible before they came crashing down in 1973-1974. Suffice it to say, the media headlines were horrific during this period.
Here is some context for this period:
- The U.S. was exiting the Vietnam War
- Economy was undergoing a major recession
- Watergate scandal and presidential resignation
- 9% unemployment
- The Arab Oil Embargo
- Surging inflation
The media’s response? Doom and gloom. Here’s an example of this sentiment from the Newsweek cover, “The Big Bad Bear,” published on September 9, 1974.
For those who sold in fear, the results were disastrous. The Dow bottomed shortly after the magazine was released and the market rebounded +61% in less than two years. Panic was the wrong move.
“The Death of Equities” (1979)
Inflation plagued the 1970s, and just before one of the longest bull markets in history, BusinessWeek declared “The Death of Equities” on its now-infamous September 1979 cover. Once again, the media acted as a perfect contrarian indicator with the Dow quadrupling over the next decade.
Dot-Com Bubble: “The Hottest Market Ever” (2000)
In March 2000, at the peak of the tech bubble, Money magazine ran a cover story: “How to Invest in the Hottest Market Ever.” Weeks later, the bubble burst. Suboptimal timing once again.
In that same timeframe, Newsweek captured the essence of FOMO with its July 5, 1999 cover: “Everyone Is Getting Rich but Me.” Right when risk was at its peak, most investors were blind to it and got sucked into the downdraft.
Source: NewsWeek
Financial Crisis – Depression 2.0 (2008)
In October 2008, the Time magazine cover encapsulated the zeitgeist of the period with a 1929 photo that included a line of desperate people waiting for food donations at a soup kitchen. Many feared a second Great Depression. Yet it was one of the best times in history to buy stocks with the Dow tripling over the next decade.
Brexit Panic (2016)
Media coverage around the U.K.’s Brexit vote to leave the EU (European Union) painted a picture of imminent recession and contagion. Instead, the media blitz surrounding Brexit turned out to be more molehill than mountain. Markets rebounded strongly and reached new highs in the subsequent months.
“Rocketman” and North Korea Missiles (2017)
Tensions flared in 2017 as North Korea tested missiles and President Trump threatened retaliation against dictator Kim Jong Un by bombing Pyongyang and “Rocket Man”. The media went into overdrive regarding the nuclear unease, but the market brushed it off and continued climbing +58% over the next few years.
COVID-19 Pandemic (2020)
With over 3 million deaths worldwide and a grinding halt to the global economy, markets initially fell roughly -35%. But as consumers stockpiled toilet paper, fast vaccine development and stimulus sparked a powerful rebound, with stocks finishing the year up +16%. Over the next two years, the Dow almost doubled.
Hostage to Our Lizard Brain
Why are we so susceptible to the sensationalist tendencies of the media? Evolution holds the answer. Humans’ DNA and brains are hard-wired to flee prey. The small almond-shaped tissue in our brain called the amygdala—or what author Seth Godin calls the “lizard brain”—evolved to respond instantly to danger. When headlines scream “crash” or “war,” our emotional brain overrides our logical one, which leads to poor long-term results. As Seth Godin explains, we’re wired to react, not reflect (Watch here). And the media knows it.
Headlines Change but the Long-Term Market Trend Doesn’t
Despite a barrage of negative headlines, stocks have remained resilient over the long run. The market has overcome wars, assassinations, currency crises, banking failures, terrorist attacks, pandemics, natural disasters, impeachments, tax hikes, recessions, restrictive Fed policies, debt downgrades, inflation, and yes, even tariffs (see chart below). Since WWII, we’ve had 12 recessions—each followed by a full recovery to new record highs. In baseball terms, the economy has batted a perfect 1.000 (12-for-12) with recession recoveries.
How to Survive the Avalanche of Media Headlines
Here are five key strategies:
- Turn off the TV: Don’t obsess over headlines. Emotional reactions result in poor decisions.
Buying high (greed) and selling low (fear) is not a recipe for long-term investment success.
- Diversify Your Investments: A well-balanced portfolio across asset classes helps reduce panic.
- Invest According to Time Horizon: Are you young? Assuming more risk and higher exposure to the stock market is generally fine. Are you near retirement? Don’t jeopardize your retirement goals – de-risk accordingly.
- Ignore Talking Heads: Most pundits don’t invest and their credibility is compromised by monetary conflicts of interest. It’s much more beneficial to follow seasoned professionals with real track records through multiple bull and bear markets.
- Avoid the Herd: Continually following the herd into the most popular investments often leads to underperformance. The grass is greener, and the food sources are more plentiful, off the beaten path trampled by the herd. Contrarian thinking works even though it can feel scary.
In the age of constant connectivity, headlines and the 24/7 news cycle are addictive. But if you’re tired of being a pawn in the media’s game, I invite you to join my fight by acknowledging that the Emperor Media has no clothes.
Wade W. Slome, CFA, CFP®
Plan. Invest. Prosper.
This article is an excerpt from a previously released Sidoxia Capital Management complimentary newsletter (May 1, 2025). Subscribe Here to view all monthly articles.
DISCLOSURE: Sidoxia Capital Management (SCM) and some of its clients hold positions in certain exchange traded funds (ETFs), but at the time of publishing had no direct position in any other security referenced in this article. No information accessed through the Investing Caffeine (IC) website constitutes investment, financial, legal, tax or other advice nor is to be relied on in making an investment or other decision. Please read disclosure language on the IC Contact page.
Extrapolation: Dangers of the Reckless Ruler
The game of investing would be rather simple if everything moved in a straight line and economic data points could be could be connected with a level ruler. Unfortunately, the real world doesn’t operate that way – data points are actually scattered continuously. In the short-run, inflation, GDP, exchange rates, interest rates, corporate earnings, profit margins, geopolitics, natural disasters, financial crises, and an infinite number of other factors are very difficult to predict with any accurate consistency. The true way to make money is to correctly identify long-term trends and then opportunistically take advantage of the chaos by using the power of mean reversion. Let me explain.
Take for example the just-released October employment figures, which on the surface showed a blowout creation of +271,000 new jobs during the month (unemployment rate decline to 5.0%) versus the Wall Street consensus forecast of +180,000 (flat unemployment rate of 5.1%). The rise in new workers was a marked acceleration from the +137,000 additions in September and the +136,000 in August. The better-than-expected jobs numbers, the highest monthly addition since late 2014, was paraded across television broadcasts and web headlines as a blowout number, which gives the Federal Reserve and Chairwoman Janet Yellen more ammunition to raise interest rates next month at the Federal Open Market Committee meeting. Investors are now factoring in roughly a 70% probability of a +0.25% interest rate hike next month compared to an approximately 30% chance of an increase a few weeks ago.
As is often the case, speculators, traders, and the media rely heavily on their trusty ruler to connect two data points to create a trend, and then subsequently extrapolate that trend out into infinity, whether the trend is moving upwards or downwards. I went back in time to explore the media’s infatuation with limitless extrapolation in my Back to the Future series (see Part I; Part II; and Part III). More recently, weakening data in China caused traders to extrapolate that weakness into perpetuity and pushed Chinese stocks down in August by more than -20% and U.S. stocks down more than -10%, over the same timeframe.
While most of the media coverage blew the recent jobs number out of proportion (see BOOM! Big Rebound in Job Creation), some shrewd investors understand mean reversion is one of the most powerful dynamics in economics and often overrides the limited utility of extrapolation. Case in point is blogger-extraordinaire Scott Grannis (Calafia Beach Pundit) who displayed this judgment when he handicapped the October jobs data a day before the statistics were released. Here’s what Grannis said:
The BLS’s estimate of private sector employment tends to be more volatile than ADP’s, and both tend to track each other over time. That further suggests that the BLS jobs number—to be released early tomorrow—has a decent chance of beating expectations.
Now, Grannis may not have guaranteed a specific number, but comparing the volatile government BLS and private sector ADP jobs data (always released before BLS) only bolsters the supremacy of mean reversion. As you can see from the chart below, both sets of data have been highly correlated and the monthly statistics have reliably varied between a range of +100k to +300k job additions over the last six years. So, although the number came in higher than expected for October, the result is perfectly consistent with the “slowly-but-surely” growing U.S. economy.
Source: Calafia Beach Pundit
While I spend much more time picking stocks than picking the direction of economic statistics, even I will agree there is a high probability the Fed moves interest rates next month. But even if Yellen acts in December, she has been very clear that this rate hike cycle will be slower than previous periods due to the weak pace of economic expansion. I agree with Grannis, who noted, “Higher rates would be a confirmation of growth, not a threat to growth.” Whatever happens next month, do yourself a favor and keep the urge of extrapolation at bay by keeping your pencil and ruler in your drawer.
Wade W. Slome, CFA, CFP®
Plan. Invest. Prosper.
DISCLOSURE: Sidoxia Capital Management (SCM) and some of its clients hold positions in certain exchange traded funds (ETFs) , but at the time of publishing, SCM had no direct position in any other security referenced in this article. No information accessed through the Investing Caffeine (IC) website constitutes investment, financial, legal, tax or other advice nor is to be relied on in making an investment or other decision. Please read disclosure language on IC Contact page.
Stock Market Tug-of-War
Image by © Royalty-Free/Corbis
Some things never change. There are several certainties in life, including death and taxes. And when it comes to investing, there are several other certainties: the never-ending existence of geopolitical concerns, and incessant worries over Fed policy.
Let’s face it, since the dawn of mankind, humans have been programmed to worry, whether it stemmed from avoiding a man-eating lion or foraging for food to survive (see Controlling the Investment Lizard Brain). Investors function in much the same way.
There is always a constant tug-of-war between bulls and bears, and if you are obsessed with following the relentless daily headlines about a Grexit (European Greek Exit) and an imminent Federal Reserve rate hike, you like many other investors will continue to experience sweaty palms, heart palpitations, and underperformance.
Despite the gloomy headlines, the bulls are currently winning the tug-of-war as measured by the 6-year boom in global stock prices, which has breached a record $70 trillion in value (see chart below).
Source: Mark J. Perry (Carpe Diem)
If you become hostage and react to the headlines about Greece, China, Fed policy, Ukraine, ISIS, Russia, Ebola, North Korea, QE Tapering, etc., not only are you ignoring the key positives fueling this bull market (see also Don’t Be a Fool, Follow the Stool) but you are also costing yourself a lot of money. While I have been watching the “sideliners” for years, they have missed a market driven by generationally low interest rates; improved employment picture (10% to 5%); tame inflation; steady improvement in housing market; fiscal deficit reductions; record corporate profits; record share buybacks and dividends; contrarian investor sentiment (leaving plenty of room for converts to join the party), and other fundamentally positive factors.
Yes, stocks will eventually go down by a significant amount – they always do. Stocks can temporarily go down based on the fear du jour (like the 10-20% declines in 2010, 2011, 2012, and 2014), but the nastier hits to stock markets always come from good old fashion cyclical recessions. As I’ve discussed before, there are no signs of a recession on the horizon, and the yield curve has been a great predictor of this trigger (see Dynamic Yield Curve in Digesting Stock Gains). Until then, the bears will be fighting an uphill battle.
Independent of recession timing, investing is a very challenging game, even for the most experienced professionals. The best long-term investors, including the likes of Warren Buffett and Peter Lynch, understand the never-ending geopolitical and Fed policy headlines are absolutely meaningless over the long run. However, media outlets, blogs, newspapers, and radio shows make money by peddling fear as economic and political concerns jump like a frog from one lily pad to the next. At Sidoxia we have a disciplined and systematic approach to creating diversified portfolios with our proprietary S.H.G.R. model (“sugar”) that screens for attractively valued investments. We believe this is the way to win the long-term tug-of-war.
Wade W. Slome, CFA, CFP®
Plan. Invest. Prosper.
DISCLOSURE: Sidoxia Capital Management (SCM) and some of its clients hold positions in certain exchange traded funds (ETFs), but at the time of publishing, SCM had no direct position in any other security referenced in this article. No information accessed through the Investing Caffeine (IC) website constitutes investment, financial, legal, tax or other advice nor is to be relied on in making an investment or other decision. Please read disclosure language on IC Contact page.
Winning via Halftime Adjustments
This article is an excerpt from a previously released Sidoxia Capital Management complementary newsletter (July 1, 2014). Subscribe on the right side of the page for the complete text.
In the game of sports and investing there are a lot of unanticipated dynamics that occur during the course of a game, season, or year. With the second quarter of 2014 now coming to a close, we have reached the half-way point of the year. Along the way, the coach (and investors) may need to make some strategic halftime adjustments. Reassessing or reflecting on the positioning of your investment portfolio once or twice per year in the context of your investment objectives, time horizon, and risk tolerance level is never a bad idea – especially when there are unforeseen events continually materializing during the game.
During the first half of the year, the financial markets have experienced numerous surprises:
- Declining Interest Rates: Under the auspices of a massive 2013 gain in stock prices, expectations were for an accelerating economy and rising interest rates in 2014. Instead, the 10-Year Treasury Note has seen its yield counterintuitively plunge from 3.03% to 2.52%.
- Geopolitical Tensions (Ukraine/Syria/Iraq): The stock market has ground higher this year in spite of geopolitical tensions in Ukraine, Syria, and now Iraq. These skirmishes make for great TV, radio, and blog content, but the reality is these conflicts will likely be forgotten/ignored in favor of other fresher clashes in the coming months and quarters.
- Unabated Tapering: It’s true the Federal Reserve signaled the reduction in its bond buying stimulus program last year, however the more surprising aspect has been the pace of the taper. From the beginning of the year, the $85 billion program has already been reduced to $35 billion and will likely be reduced to $0 by the fall.
- Polar Vortex/GDP: Weather is very unpredictable, and regardless of your views on global warming, the unseasonably cold weather on the eastern half of the country had a severely negative impact on first half GDP (Gross Domestic Product). In fact, first quarter GDP was revised lower to a contraction of -2.9%. The good news is expectations are for an improved second half of the year according to Merrill Lynch.
While it would be wonderful to live in Utopia, unfortunately for investors, there is always uncertainty and risk. These elements come with the investing territory. Of course, you can always compensate for that unwanted uncertainty by accepting low interest-paying options (e.g., stuffing your money under a mattress, in a CD, savings account, Treasury bonds, etc.).
Despite the unexpected first half events, the market continues to grind higher. During the first half of the year, the S&P 500 index rose 6.1% (+1.9% in June); the Dow Jones Industrials edged higher by +1.5% (+0.7% in June); and the Nasdaq climbed +5.5% (+3.9% in June). But stocks weren’t the only winning investment team in town – bonds tasted victory during the first half also, notching gains of +2.8% (AGG – Aggregate Bond), almost double the Dow’s performance.
Investor Psyche Pendulum Swinging in Positive Direction
As I have written in the past, investor psyches continually swing along an emotional pendulum (see also Sentiment Pendulum article) from a state of “Panic” to “Euphoria”. While the pendulum has clearly swung in a positive direction, away from the emotional states of “Panic & Fear,” we appear to now be between “Skepticism & Hope.” The timing of when we get to the latter stages of “Optimism & Euphoria” is dependent on the pace of the economic recovery, risk appetites of consumers/businesses, and the trajectory of risky assets like stocks. Just because the ride has been fun for the last five years, does not mean the ride is over. However, as the pendulum continues to swing to the left, long-term investors need to fight the tempting urge to increase risk appetite just as the allure of high stock returns appears more achievable.
During the second half of this economic cycle, before the next recession, investors need to be more cognizant of controlling risk (the probability of permanent losses) by paying closer attention to valuations, diversification, and rebalancing too heavily weighted equity portfolios.
Besides rising stock prices and the beginning of positive fund flows, investors’ increasing appetite for risk is evidenced by the yield chasing occurring in junk bonds, which has raised prices of the lowest quality bonds to lofty levels. The chart below shows this phenomenon happening with the yields narrowing between high yield (HY) bonds and investment grade (IG) corporate bonds.
Source: Calafia Beach Pundit
Even though I pointed out a number of disconcerting surprises in the first half of the year, as you consider making halftime adjustments to your portfolios, do not forget some of the underlying positive currents that are leading to a winning halftime score.
Here are some of the constructive factors supporting stock prices, which have nearly tripled in value from the 2009 lows (S&P 500 – 666 to 1,960):
Record Corporate Profits: I constantly bump into skeptics who fail to realize the fundamental power of record profits driving stock prices higher (see chart below). As the late John Templeton stated, “In the long run, the stock market indexes fluctuate around the long-term upward trend of earnings per share.”
Source: Dr. Ed’s Blog
Improving Consumer Confidence: The University of Michigan consumer sentiment index increased to 82.5 for June from May. The confidence score came in above the consensus forecast of 82.0. Confidence has increased significantly from the 2009 lows but as the chart below shows, there is plenty of room for this metric to advance – consistent with the emotion pendulum discussed previously.
Source: Calculated Risk
Dividends & Share Buybacks Near Record Levels: A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush. Corporations have realized this investor desire and as a result companies are returning record levels of money (“capital”) to stock shareholders via increasing dividends and share buybacks (see chart below).
Source: Dr. Ed’s Blog
Housing on the Mend: The housing market has improved in fits and starts, but the most recent data point of new home sales shows significant improvement. More specifically, May’s new home sales were up +18.6% from the previous month (see chart below), the highest level seen since 2008. Although this data is encouraging, there is still plenty of room for improvement, as current sales remain more than 50% below 2005 peak levels.
Source: Calculated Risk
Record Industrial Production: Adding support to the improving economic outlook are the industrial production figures, which also hit a record (see chart below). This data also adds credence to why the U.S. stock market has outperformed the European markets during the economic recovery from 2009.
Source: Calafia Beach Pundit
Declining Federal Deficit: The federal deficit continues to narrow (i.e., tax revenues growing faster than government spending), so previous fiscally panicked screams have quieted down. We’re not out of the woods yet, but the trends are encouraging (see chart below):
Source: Calafia Beach Pundit
There have been plenty of bombshells during the first half of 2014 (no pun intended), and there are bound to be plenty more during the second half of the year. By definition, nobody can be fully prepared for a surprise, or else it wouldn’t be called a “surprise”. For those skeptical investors sitting on the sidelines, the record breaking stock market performance has also been astonishing. Regardless of what happens over the next six months, periodically making adjustments to your financial plan is important, whether it’s during the pre-game, post-game, or halftime. And if you’re not interested or capable of making those adjustments yourself, find a professional advisor/coach to assist you.
Wade W. Slome, CFA, CFP®
Plan. Invest. Prosper.
DISCLOSURE: Sidoxia Capital Management (SCM) and some of its clients hold long positions in certain exchange traded funds and AGG, but at the time of publishing SCM had no direct position in any other security referenced in this article. No information accessed through the Investing Caffeine (IC) website constitutes investment, financial, legal, tax or other advice nor is to be relied on in making an investment or other decision. Please read disclosure language on IC Contact page.
Investing Caffeine 
